I got these to go with my extra wide calf boots and boy was it a mistake! They are far too tight. I bought them hoping I could just leave them in my boots, but if I want to use them at all I have to put them on first and then put my boots on. I also can't really use them when I have pants on other than leggings or skinny jeans and even then it's a struggle to get them on and they are uncomfortably tight. I really have not been using them and thus have not been using my boots because it's too cold here now to not have the liners. So disappointed. The one good thing I can say about them is that they are good quality, seem well made, and are nice and warm. I just wish I could actually use them.